Now, that said, I have to say on finishing the the graphic novel that it was well done. I quite enjoyed it. It was very respectful to the original material. In reading this, I heard Madeleine L'Engle speaking the lines (she reads the audio book, you HAVE to listen to it). I think she would have liked this as much as she disliked the TV movie some years back (I really didn't mind the movie & I know I'm in the minority).
Now THAT said, I agree with other reviewers out in the blogosphere, the color choice was just poor. When you have a character called "Man with red eyes" and his eyes are actually robin's egg blue...it just doesn't work. If the color had been red/pink, it would have worked better...but I think we should have gone black and white or full-ish color. So bad marks on the color choice. Other than that I really liked the are work.